Flashback 2002: Jerry Brown says 'it's not viable' for poverty stricken developing world to emulate prosperity of U.S.  

Originally Published by Cybercast News Service on September 3, 2002

Jerry Brown to World's Poor: Let Them Eat Cake?

By Marc Morano - CNSNews.com Senior Staff Writer - Johannesburg (CNSNews.com) - Former Democratic Governor of California Jerry Brown believes that poverty stricken residents of the developing world who want to emulate American prosperity should not be allowed to do so because "it's not viable."

In an exclusive interview, CNSNews.com asked Brown whether he thought the residents of the poorest nations of the world wanted to develop economically as the U.S. has done.

"Many do, but it's not viable," Brown replied. "I would say we can't develop like us, nor them...the developed model cannot work without another five planets," he added.

A British author critical of the Green movement, Professor Philip Stott, said Brown's anti-development views, as relayed to him, can be likened to Marie Antoinette's reported response when she was told the French peasants had no bread to eat: "Let them eat cake."

"I am deeply worried when I hear a white, Western, male start to lecture the developing world on what they should, or should not, want," Stott told CNSNews.com.

Brown, the current mayor of Oakland, Calif., appeared at the U.N.'s Summit on Sustainable Development (or Earth summit) on behalf of the environmental group Global Greens. Brown, who earned the nickname "Governor Moonbeam" for his somewhat unconventional style, appeared in numerous panel discussions while at the summit.

In the interview, Brown defended the Green group's efforts to stop infrastructure projects deemed too ecologically destructive in countries like India and Brazil. The projects would have brought running water and electricity to the poor residents of the nations.

"One thing you have to realize is the economy is inside the environment, not the other way around," an unapologetic Brown replied. [...]

A British author critical of the Green movement, Professor Philip Stott, said Brown's anti-development views, as relayed to him, can be likened to Marie Antoinette's reported response when she was told the French peasants had no bread to eat: "Let them eat cake."

• New
• Popular
• Past 7 days

1. The U.S. Intense Hurricane Drought: 'Record-long stretch of no intense hurricane landfalls still continuing'
2. Climate Depot's Morano: 'Every day now, skeptics are compared to Holocaust deniers & the media yawns' -- MSM Condemns Heartland's Billboard, Ignores What Alarmists Do Everyday
3. Letter to Ed in NYT on Hansen: Consensus?! 'European scientists in the 15th century agreed that the earth was the center of the universe. That didn't make it true'
4. Does NASA's Hansen Ever Look At Actual Data? 'His claims of permanent drought are not consistent with US drought record, which shows a decrease in drought & increase in wetness since 1895'
5. Study: Shopping malls prevent animals from escaping global warming: ' '9% of Western Hemisphere´s mammals are not able to run fast enough in order to flee catastrophic global warming'
6. Arctic seabirds doing fine despite of 'global warming': 'Little auks, the most common seabirds in the Arctic, are adapting their fishing behavior to warming surface waters in the Greenland Sea'
7. Global Warming Predicted Hotspot Over Tropics Is Non-Existent: 'Empirical measurements confirm Hansen's predicted tropical hotspot has not happened, it's a 'coldspot' instead'
8. NASA's Hansen warns of end times! Global warming increasing by 'equivalent to exploding 400,000 Hiroshima atomic bombs per day 365 days per year'
9. Greenie Grist Mag. laments lack of interest in AGW.: 'The most critical issue ever to face humanity is getting less attention this election season than dogs'
10. New paper in journal Weather finds large increase in sunshine since the 1980's; dwarfs alleged effect of CO2
11. New paper in journal Weather finds large increase in sunshine since the 1980's; dwarfs alleged effect of CO2
12. Panel discussion: Ethics, Stanford: A question of balance
13. New paper finds solar activity and natural climate cycles explain rainfall variations over past 160 years
14. New paper finds planetary motions explain climate; predicts stable climate: Study in Journal of Atmospheric & Solar-Terrestrial Physics
15. New paper finds 'no model consensus' on precipitation projections: Journal of Geophysical Research study finds 19 different models had 'no model consensus'

1. The U.S. Intense Hurricane Drought: 'Record-long stretch of no intense hurricane landfalls still continuing'
2. Climate Depot's Morano: 'Every day now, skeptics are compared to Holocaust deniers & the media yawns' -- MSM Condemns Heartland's Billboard, Ignores What Alarmists Do Everyday
3. Letter to Ed in NYT on Hansen: Consensus?! 'European scientists in the 15th century agreed that the earth was the center of the universe. That didn't make it true'
4. Does NASA's Hansen Ever Look At Actual Data? 'His claims of permanent drought are not consistent with US drought record, which shows a decrease in drought & increase in wetness since 1895'
5. Study: Shopping malls prevent animals from escaping global warming: ' '9% of Western Hemisphere´s mammals are not able to run fast enough in order to flee catastrophic global warming'
6. Arctic seabirds doing fine despite of 'global warming': 'Little auks, the most common seabirds in the Arctic, are adapting their fishing behavior to warming surface waters in the Greenland Sea'
7. Global Warming Predicted Hotspot Over Tropics Is Non-Existent: 'Empirical measurements confirm Hansen's predicted tropical hotspot has not happened, it's a 'coldspot' instead'
8. NASA's Hansen warns of end times! Global warming increasing by 'equivalent to exploding 400,000 Hiroshima atomic bombs per day 365 days per year'
9. Greenie Grist Mag. laments lack of interest in AGW.: 'The most critical issue ever to face humanity is getting less attention this election season than dogs'
10. New paper in journal Weather finds large increase in sunshine since the 1980's; dwarfs alleged effect of CO2
11. New paper in journal Weather finds large increase in sunshine since the 1980's; dwarfs alleged effect of CO2
12. Panel discussion: Ethics, Stanford: A question of balance
13. New paper finds solar activity and natural climate cycles explain rainfall variations over past 160 years
14. New paper finds planetary motions explain climate; predicts stable climate: Study in Journal of Atmospheric & Solar-Terrestrial Physics
15. New paper finds 'no model consensus' on precipitation projections: Journal of Geophysical Research study finds 19 different models had 'no model consensus'

1. The U.S. Intense Hurricane Drought: 'Record-long stretch of no intense hurricane landfalls still continuing'
2. Climate Depot's Morano: 'Every day now, skeptics are compared to Holocaust deniers & the media yawns' -- MSM Condemns Heartland's Billboard, Ignores What Alarmists Do Everyday
3. Letter to Ed in NYT on Hansen: Consensus?! 'European scientists in the 15th century agreed that the earth was the center of the universe. That didn't make it true'
4. Does NASA's Hansen Ever Look At Actual Data? 'His claims of permanent drought are not consistent with US drought record, which shows a decrease in drought & increase in wetness since 1895'
5. Study: Shopping malls prevent animals from escaping global warming: ' '9% of Western Hemisphere´s mammals are not able to run fast enough in order to flee catastrophic global warming'
6. Arctic seabirds doing fine despite of 'global warming': 'Little auks, the most common seabirds in the Arctic, are adapting their fishing behavior to warming surface waters in the Greenland Sea'
7. Global Warming Predicted Hotspot Over Tropics Is Non-Existent: 'Empirical measurements confirm Hansen's predicted tropical hotspot has not happened, it's a 'coldspot' instead'
8. NASA's Hansen warns of end times! Global warming increasing by 'equivalent to exploding 400,000 Hiroshima atomic bombs per day 365 days per year'
9. Greenie Grist Mag. laments lack of interest in AGW.: 'The most critical issue ever to face humanity is getting less attention this election season than dogs'
10. New paper in journal Weather finds large increase in sunshine since the 1980's; dwarfs alleged effect of CO2
11. New paper in journal Weather finds large increase in sunshine since the 1980's; dwarfs alleged effect of CO2
12. Panel discussion: Ethics, Stanford: A question of balance
13. New paper finds solar activity and natural climate cycles explain rainfall variations over past 160 years
14. New paper finds planetary motions explain climate; predicts stable climate: Study in Journal of Atmospheric & Solar-Terrestrial Physics
15. New paper finds 'no model consensus' on precipitation projections: Journal of Geophysical Research study finds 19 different models had 'no model consensus'